The Guzzi small block has been in production for close to 40 years and is well developed and well sorted. I haven’t ridden a V7 Classic myself, but by all accounts it’s a great bike and owners seem to love them. The non-C.A.R.C. shaft is solid. There were some problems with the early C.A.R.C. shafts on the big blocks, but those seem to have been resolved.
Moto Guzzi has a great sound and tons of character. It’s hard to describe, but it’s much like Italian cars: there’s just something about them that’s different than anything else. They’re not necessarily smoother, faster, better handling, or anything else, but they somehow just manage to feel “right” and push all the right buttons. The V7C has gotten rave reviews from Guzzista – for whatever that’s worth.
Moto Guzzi is not without its issues though. Mechanically, they have a history of small problems that are usually fairly easy to fix, but troublesome just the same. Fuel pump issues on recent bikes are a good example. I’m not sure if the V7C is involved or not, but I know that there have been fuel pump problems with some recent Guzzis. The fuel pump is inside the tank and uses fuel line that is not alcohol resistant and is not adequately clamped to the pump. Consequently, here in the land of gasohol, the fuel lines swell and/or deteriorate, pop off of the pump, and leave you pumping fuel around the tank rather than to the injectors. Fairly easy to fix, but not something you should have to fix on a new motorcycle. These problems are exacerbated by a small dealer network and an even smaller
good dealer network.
Take a look at
this thread on wildguzzi for one horror story and some interesting quotes from Guzzi riders. Things like count on spending an additional 10% to finish the bike. Or maybe the first 20K miles can be frustrating, but the next 180K will be great. Like every other bike on the market, there’s a small percentage of them that really have problems, but those get a lot of attention.
Another issue is that Moto Guzzi seems to be perpetually on the ropes. Once again, they are in transition. On the verge of closing the doors for good in 2004, Moto Guzzi was bought by Aprilia. Then before too long Aprilia found themselves in trouble as well and they were recently bought by the Piaggio group. Right now it seems to be nearly impossible to get solid information on what is in the cards for Moto Guzzi. Piaggio has publicly stated that they intend to keep making Moto Guzzis, but they haven’t said a lot more than that. There are also seemingly hundreds of stories floating around as to the future of the factory in Mandello. Some say it’s closing, some say it’s closed, and some say that it just shut down for the summer for the model changeover and is now back open. And each story seems to be backed up by press releases from Piaggio, Italian news stories, and trade journals.
I know all this sounds pretty negative, but it’s really more of an effort to be sure that your eyes are open if you should choose a Guzzi. Personally, I love Moto Guzzis. I never really cared for the Ambassador or the Eldorado, but I fell in love with the V50 in the early 80s and have been a Moto Guzzi fan ever since. My 1200 Sport is a more fun than a barrel of monkeys and has been absolutely flawless. Based in part on my experience, my brother-in-law went out and bought a new, leftover ’07 Griso about three weeks ago. He only has ~500 miles on it so far, but his too has been flawless.
For something a little more positive, I would also recommend
this blog by Danilo Gurovich. He’s a long-time Guzzi guy who recently replaced his wrecked 1200 Sport with a V7 Classic. He’s an admitted Guzzi guy, but he cross shopped the Bonnie and the Ducati 1000GT. Obviously, he ended up with the Goose. His blog helped me a lot in my decision to buy my 1200 Sport. I find that I get a lot more out of reading reviews from real riders and owners than I do from magazine or e-zine tests where some hotshoe spends a couple hours riding a bike from the press fleet.
Whatever you decide, good luck. In my opinion, either of the choices you listed is a winner.