Great pics and video... thanks for putting the RR up.
Feel free to hang out and lurk as long as you like. However, we would like to encourage you to register so that you can join the community and use the numerous features on the site. After registering, don't forget to post up an introduction!
Thanks for letting me stop and play. Sometimes folks just want to ride, but it makes for good memories later.Jason - fantastic job on the videos. The drone footage is very impressive. What a great ride report.
I have been using one of the Original "dumb" SPOTs from right when they came out. I use it on track so Linda and others have an idea where I am. I only have one experience with using the "911" button. See here:Thoughts on insurance, satellite communicators, and preparation.
So, here are some thoughts I have on these items, based on the amount of research I did before this trip, and experiences I've had and witnessed.
Two years prior to this trip, one of the guys in the group, John H, had a nasty crash in Utah and injured his back. His buddies were able to get a hold of emergency services and get him helicoptered out of there. Thankfully he had insurance for this kind of thing and it was a no brainer. I went into super research mode on this stuff and purchased my own insurance based on his story. Mike had planned on getting the insurance, but for many reasons he didn't complete the purchase. This put him in a pickle of a position there on the side of the trail and the cost of the ride put him in the position of declining the assistance. It's an expensive prospect and one you shouldn't be concerning yourself with when you are hurting out in the middle of nowhere. The insurance is cheap and if you are planning any kind of trip like this, just get the insurance so you don't have the dilemma at a time you just need to be focusing on other things.
Additionally, making the wrong decision can have dangerous consequences. It was 11 hours from the time of the accident to the time Mike was in the hands of medical professionals. He got lucky there, but you run a lot of risk of medical complications taking place during a long wait time like that. This is the reason they want to send you a helicopter, it's the fastest way to get you help.
I did some research between Garmin and Spot on the insurance provided and found some interesting stuff there. Garmin has excellent reviews dating back to the beginning of Garmin's offering of this service. Spot's reviews aren't so good in the past. The difference in the two companies is that Garmin runs their service and Spot contracts theirs out to a third party. Interestingly enough, a couple of years ago, their third party was purchased by Garmin. Not wanting to give business to their competitor, they moved over to their current provider, Overwatch X. The reviews since this transition seem to be good so it's kind of a wash between them. Coverage is very similar with some small differences that are worth reviewing but ultimately if you already have a device, you won't go wrong picking the coverage offered by that device.
In my research in all of this, I already had a Spot Gen 4, but looked into the Garmin side as well, specifically at the Mini 2. I like that the current devices support some type of two way communication whether on the device itself or connected to your phone. This proved to be a big plus in that Mike was able to have a two way conversation with emergency services. He was able to know someone was on the other end and was able to make decisions. On my device, I push the button and then I hope someone gets the message and is coming to get me. I have zero input on the type of assistance I'm getting and the folks on the other end have no idea what kind of help I actually need. Of course, these devices that support two way communication can function like mine if I'm not able to have a digital conversation in my situation.
I ultimately decided to stay with my Spot Gen 4 because of some things going on with Garmin. Their basic communication tech has been the same for a long time with little changes despite newer models. Apparently they've recently released an upgrade version of their larger communicator that uses new protocols and tech for the communication. There's anticipation of these changes being pushed to the next version of the Mini, so I didn't feel like making that investment at this time. I also didn't see the benefit of the two way communication until we were actually using it. I'm hoping to have a new device on my next adventure, but we'll see which way I go with it.
----------------------------------------------------
The elephant in the room is the built in technology in modern phones that looks to put Garmin and Spot out of business. Before the trip, I had watched a few videos of this and determined that it's probably not ready for prime time. Actually experiencing this proved to me that I wouldn't recommend this to anyone right now.
The first thing that was obvious was having to point the phone at the satellite. The iPhone will help you find the satellite and assist you in getting it oriented correctly for the communication to happen. That's a bit fiddly when you are lying on the ground trying to get a help message out. Additionally, the satellites are passing overhead, so there's not always one readily in view and you have to find it and align things and get the messages sent and received. Being able to push a button on the spot and it'll connect on it's own when it sees the satellite makes things easy. This was more difficult as the cliff behind us blocked view of the satellite, so we had half the effective communication time before the satellite was no longer available to us. Heaven forbid if you fell in a crevasse or narrow canyon. I can't say if Spot or Garmin would be able to communicate, but at least you wouldn't be holding your phone trying to find something.
The biggest impact was the battery. Mike crashed toward the end of the day. When he pulled his phone out, he had 30% battery on his phone. The biggest things that chew up the battery are screen use and your phone trying to establish communications. Those two things will eat your available battery level quickly out in the middle of nowhere. Mike's battery was going down at an alarming rate while using the screen to find satellites and get his text messages in and out. At some points he ended up turning his phone off to conserve energy in case he needed to send a message later. He had a tire inflator that had the ability to act as a charging block, but something had happened to it and it wasn't functioning properly and wouldn't charge his phone, so his backup wasn't worth anything. All of this added a lot of stress to the situation. That said, he was able to communicate with 911, his wife, and our friends back at the RV camp, so it did have a lot of benefit. That said, it's very easy to end up in a situation where you aren't able to communicate at all. The batteries on my Spot have easily lasted through a full two week trip while sending data all day long. I also carry spare AAA batteries for it as well so I'd be pretty confident that it can handle the communications during an emergency. The phone tech is cool, and will be better in the future, but it's not where I'd put my confidence in it for a potential life and death situation.
As for getting assistance from others, this is great if you crash along the interstate, but even a popular place like we were at, was still far too remote for hoping for help. During our four and a half our wait on the side of the trail, we did not see a single person. No Jeeps, no SxS, no motorcyclists, no bicyclists, no hikers. When our buddies got back to camp, they dialed 911 and even though we had folks coming to get us they requested for Search and Rescue to come out just in case. Not sure how it'd be inside something like a National Park, outside of that like where we were, it's all a volunteer thing. Getting the volunteers contacted and mobilized in their personal vehicles and out to your location takes quite a bit of time. We met up with two guys from S&R in a well modified 4Runner on our way back in Mike's truck.
There's a lot to think about for these situations, and you have to decide for yourself how you want to be prepared. Going forward I'll definitely have a dedicated two way satellite communication device and carry the insurance.
LS, I like cougars. But at my age most of them are in nursing homes, and my toes are battered and bruised from their mobility chairs. Maybe I do need a gun.If you ride solo, make sure to pack a pistola too. If you can't move and your signal is blocked, you need a way to fend off the cougars.

Yes...it was easy bait on your part.I was wondering who I would snare with the cougar comment. Well done. That was hilarious TNC.